Species comp results.....

[Adam F]

Mike,

 

I'm trying to find time to pull them all together, Ive got a mixture of email, posts on here, text messgaes and voice mails to collate!

 

I'll get it done shortly.

[Adam F]

Still waiting on one or two more to come back in, but so far I have:

 

Position Points Angler Score

 

1 20 Alun Jones 54

2 19 Gordon Moore 42

3 18 Chris Gould 39

4 17 Dan Chapman 28

5 16 Mike Fox 26

6 15 Neal Sturt 24

7 14 John Young 14

8 13 Mark Winfield 14

9 12 Mike Norman 12

10 11 Richard Biggs 12

11 10 Carol Fox 8

12 9 Bill Smith 8

13 8 Rachael Franklin 8

12 7 Gordon Holt 6

15 6 George Fox 6

16 5 Sam Annear 6

17 4 Dave Samual 5

18 3 Paul Dore 4

19 2 Carl Hurran 4

20 1 Adam Franklin 3

20 1 Charlie Annear 2

20 1 Aaron Murray 1

 

[charlieannear]

Thanks Adam.

I note there's no 14th on this list!

 

I may well be missing something, but should the people with same score all get same position and points?

 

1 20 Alun Jones 54

2 19 Gordon Moore 42

3 18 Chris Gould 39

4 17 Dan Chapman 28

5 16 Mike Fox 26

6 15 Neal Sturt 24

=7 14 John Young 14

=7 14 Mark Winfield 14

=9 12 Mike Norman 12

=9 12 Richard Biggs 12

=11 10 Carol Fox 8

=11 10 Bill Smith 8

=11 10 Rachael Franklin 8

=14 7 Gordon Holt 6

=14 7 George Fox 6

=14 7 Sam Annear 6

17 4 Dave Samuel 5

=18 3 Paul Dore 4

=18 3 Carl Hurran 4

20 1 Adam Franklin 3

21 1 Charlie Annear 2

22 1 Aaron Murray 1

 

Apologies if I'm forgetting something about our scoring.

 

Also, it might be a bit humiliating when people don't catch anything, but should they still say they were there and be on the list?

Shows how many people *really* entered the comp

It might show that comps are better attended than we may think?

i.e sometimes organisers get the hump because it looks like ony 6 people fished a comp, when it might have actually been 16 with 10 people not catching?

It can make a big difference if talking percentages attending comps, for example about 20% attendance on this Species hunt if you go by the final list, but add in non-scorers and it might be more like 30%

14th out of 30 rather than 14th out of 21 is more encouraging too? Especially for newbies and youngsters?

Or does it matter?

 

Sorry if I've got completely the wrong end of the stick!

[great white]

Charlie

I think you have it right. But Adam is running it now so its down to him.

 

But as these are one off comps its not as important as it was when it was a series of comps.

 

It was agreed when we adopted this system that all that fished would get at least 1 point.

 

 

Charlie

 

[Adam F]

Updated now:

 

Position Points Angler Score

1 20 Alun Jones 54

2 19 Charlie Chapman 45

3 18 Gordon Moore 42

4 17 Chris Gould 39

5 16 Dan Chapman 28

6 15 Mike Fox 26

7 14 Neal Sturt 24

8 13 John Young 14

9 12 Mark Winfield 14

10 11 Mike Norman 12

11 10 Richard Biggs 12

12 9 Carol Fox 8

13 8 Bill Smith 8

14 7 Rachael Franklin 8

15 6 Gordon Holt 6

16 5 George Fox 6

17 4 Sam Annear 6

18 3 Dave Samual 5

19 2 Paul Dore 4

20 1 Carl Hurran 4

20 1 Adam Franklin 3

20 1 Charlie Annear 2

20 1 Aaron Murray 1

 

I have no issue with adding those who fished but didnt catch, but to be honest it's been quite a task pulling this together with the varied format I received the results in.

 

 

[biggcol]

Adam

 

Our results seem to be missing for BOBLIN

 

Bobi had 4 Ballans, 1 LSD and 1 Pollack

 

Colin (me) had 4 Ballans, 4 LSD, 1 Gar, 1 Pout, and 1 Scorpionfish

 

My internet has been down but i did send a text with the results

 

Cheers

Colin

 

Ps can someone just confirm it is 4 of each species cos we did have more of the same

Edited April 23, 2009 by biggcol

[Manic Moore]

 

 

Charlie you spawney get

[Paul D]

Adam

 

Our results seem to be missing for BOBLIN

 

Bobi had 4 Ballans, 1 LSD and 1 Pollack

 

Colin (me) had 4 Ballans, 4 LSD, 1 Gar, 1 Pout, and 1 Scorpionfish

 

My internet has been down but i did send a text with the results

 

Cheers

Colin

 

Ps can someone just confirm it is 4 of each species cos we did have more of the same

Colin,

 

Yes, it is four of a species but only those on the nfsa list so I think Scorpion fish does not count,

 

regards Paul

[Paul D]

Mike,

 

I'm trying to find time to pull them all together, Ive got a mixture of email, posts on here, text messgaes and voice mails to collate!

 

I'll get it done shortly.

Welcome to my ( old ) world

[great white]

Charlie you spawney get

Nice

 

I see who wants the cracked cup next week

 

 

Paul

Is there a bit of relief there mate?

 

Charlie

[petesnr]

I did post that I had caught 1 bream but do not appear in the results.

 

Peter R Senior

[biggcol]

Thanks for that, but what happened to the good old standby of UNCLASSIFIED

[Sinbad]

Am I missing something????

 

Didnt Adam get outfished by Mrs Franklin???

 

 

 

Put me down as Unclassified as well, as I was still in the boat yard on 'maintenance'

 

Sorry Adam!

 

 

 

[biggcol]

Do we have the final results yet

[Adam F]

Sorry guys - still had results coming in until the last few days. I think we may need to look at a cut off for results and maybe a more consistant format of reporting - but anyway thats for another meeting and discussion.

 

Thanks to all who did fish - great turn out and thanks to all who sent results through. Final results below:

 

Position Points Angler Score

1 20 Alun Jones 54

2 19 Charlie Chapman 45

3 18 Colin Francis 43

4 17 Gordon Moore 42

5 16 Chris Gould 39

6 15 Dan Chapman 28

7 14 Bobbi Francis 27

8 13 Mike Fox 26

9 12 Neal Sturt 24

10 11 John Young 14

10 11 Mark Winfield 14

11 10 Mike Norman 12

11 10 Richard Biggs 12

12 9 Carol Fox 8

12 9 Bill Smith 8

12 9 Rachael Franklin 8

13 8 Gordon Holt 6

13 8 George Fox 6

13 8 Sam Annear 6

14 7 Dave Samual 5

15 6 Paul Dore 4

15 6 Carl Hurran 4

16 5 Pete Russell Snr 3

16 5 Adam Franklin 3

17 4 Charlie Annear 2

18 3 Aaron Murray 1

19 2 Paul Fray 0