Personally, I like to see the big ones go back and keep the smaller ones which are better for the pot, except Rays which all go back. I find it hard to kill them for some reason...they seem too intelligent!!??!!
And we have good examples of guys in the club doing the same things...Rich with his double figure bass, Adam with his 31lb Cod (but alas it wouldn't go back), the Chapmans with their Tope, etc, etc, etc.
BF